Part of the debate "The NHS should not treat self-inflicted illness"
Opposer: Charles Foster
Update 2
Dr. Sheehan has fairly and inevitably surrendered. The motion as it stands is wholly unarguable.
But he contends that there are still important matters to discuss. I agree. Let's look at the 'subset of extreme examples' he relies on, where it is blindingly obvious that injury has been self-inflicted. The three clearest examples are perhaps attempted suicides, injuries resulting from dangerous sports, and some road traffic accidents.
We need to start by chasing away one red herring: insurance. Of course bungee jumpers and parachutists should be insured. Insurance is mandatory for drivers. I have no difficulty with the proposition that the NHS should recoup the cost of care from the bungee jumper's insurer. But let's suppose that the insurance company won't pay. There could be many reasons. The jumper's wife might have failed to post a letter; the tour operator, unbeknown to the jumper, might not have been on the insurer's approved list; the insurer might litigate long and hard to avoid liability on a technicality.
Read More »Oxford Debates Cont’d – Opposer’s update 2